Evaluation

Executive Summary
[ PDF: 42kb | 6 pages ]

Maps
[ PDF: 6,378kb | 6 pages ]

1. Introduction
1. Objectives and Goal of the Country Assistance Program Evaluation
2. Scope of the Country Assistance Program Evaluation
3. Evaluation Methodology of the Country Assistance Program Evaluation
2. Development Context and the Government's Strategic Priorities
3. Assessment of Quality at Entry of Country Strategies: Relevance and Positioning
1. Relevance of Country Strategies to the Government's National Development Strategies/Plans
2. Relevance of Country Strategies to the Country's Socioeconomic Issues
3. Relevance of Country Strategies to the Asian Development Bank's Corporate Strategies
4. Harmonization of Country Strategies with Other Key Development Partners
5. Positioning of Country Strategies
4. Assessment of Quality at Entry of Country Programs: Positioning
1. Sufficient Background Research on Sector/Thematic Strategies
2. Government's Absorptive Capacity and Ownership
3. The Asian Development Bank's Comparative Advantage and Partnerships with Other Development Partners
4. Focus/Selectivity and Synergies
5. Long-Term Continuity
6. Constraints/Risks and Adjustment/Monitoring Mechanism to Achieve Measurable Targets
7. All Criteria Combined
5. Results Achievement: Bottom-Up Assessment of Effectiveness
1. Program Contributions to Achieving Intermediate Outcomes by Sector
2. Program Contributions to Achieving Intermediate Outcomes by Theme
3. Program Contributions to Achieving the Country Strategy Objective of Poverty Reduction
6. Results Achievement: Top-Down Assessment of Long-Term Development Impacts and the Millennium Development Goals
1. Program Contributions to The Country's Achievement of Long-Term Impacts
2. Exogenous Factors
3. Country's Challenges and Prospects: Future within Reach?
7. Program Implementation: Assessment of Efficiency
1. Project Performance Rating
2. Financial Performance
3. Factors Affecting Implementation Performance
8. Program Attribution: Assessment of Other Aspects
1. Government Performance
2. The Asian Development Bank's Performance
3. Harmonization and Partnerships
4. Nongovernment Organizations' Role
9. Overall Performance Assessment and Rating
1. Sector-Level Performance (Bottom-Up)
2. Strategic- and Country-Level Performance (Top-Down)
3. Overall Rating of All Levels of Performance
10. Key Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendations
    [ PDF: 27kb | 4 pages ]
1. Key Factors Contributing to Delivery of Results
2. Lessons from Past and Ongoing Operations
3. Recommendations

Appendixes
[ PDF: 831kb | 106 pages ]

1. Field Visit/Survey Sites and Socioeconomic Data
2. Quality at Entry of the Country Strategies and Programs: The Asian Development Bank's Corporate Strategies
3. Asian Development Bank's Lending and Nonlending Assistance Programs
4. Detailed Bottom-Up Assessment of Sector Performance
5. Portfolio Performance of Lending Program
6. Questionnaire for Client/Stakeholder Surveys
7. Harmonization of Development Partners' Strategies and Programs
8. Government's Fiscal Sustainability Prospects by Sector

Management Response
[ PDF: 23kb | 5 pages ]

DEC Chair Summary
[ PDF: 36kb | 4 pages ]