Publications

Home : Publications : Online Publications : Document


Table of Contents
p. 14 of 19 BACK | NEXT
Emerging Global Water Issues
Water Quality, Pollution, and the Environment
A Double-Edged Sword: Flood and Droughts
Geographical Variability in Water Resources
Shared Waters
Heightened Awareness of Water Issues
Elements of a Water Strategy
Imperatives for Wise Water Management
From Development to Water Resource Management
>> From Public Good to Priced Commodity
Future Water Resource Projects
ADB's Evolving Role in the Changing Context
Water in the 21st Century : Imperatives for Wise Water Management

From Public Good to Priced Commodity

Improving the efficiency of water use is indispensable. In the United States, contrary to all expectations, total water use has declined by 10 percent since 1980, even with population growth and a continued increase in economic wealth. Industrial use has declined by 40 percent from a peak in 1970, while industrial output and productivity have both increased. Similarly, in Japan, where industrial output has soared since the 1970s, total industrial water use has fallen by 25 percent. These reductions have been achieved through technological improvements (using less water to produce the same goods) and a change in the composition of industries making up the sector. The potential to reduce industrial use through further innovation, improved technology, and cost incentives is 20-30 percent. Comparable saving is possible in developing countries.

Residential water use, although only a small part (about 10 percent) of total water use, can be reduced without sacrificing living standards. Readily available means include improving the efficiency of household appliances, better pricing structures, use of recycled water for certain applications, and especially reducing unaccounted-for water due to leaks and nonmetered connections in aging distribution networks. In many cities, such as Dhaka, Jakarta, and Manila, nonrevenue water exceeds 50 percent of water use.

The single largest variable in future water use for human needs is irrigation. According to the UN's Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, irrigation in Asia and the Pacific accounts for 80 percent of total withdrawals, compared with 70 percent globally. By far the largest share of investments in agriculture during the green revolution era went into irrigation schemes. These were often-and remain-heavily subsidized. The adopted technology was generally at the lowest end of the scale: as much as 60 percent of the water is lost through leakage and evaporation before it even reaches the crop and an additional 20 percent may be lost on the field.6 There are few incentives for the service providers or the farmers to improve the efficiency of water delivery and use in such schemes where water is free or priced well below its cost.

Agriculture's contribution to national income is declining in all DMCs. The agriculture sector is, therefore, coming under increasing pressure to release water to meet other, more productive needs. For producing high-value crops in water-scarce areas, new irrigation techniques have been shown to be highly efficient and cost-effective. Even simple improvements in surface canal systems, which are used almost exclusively in developing countries, can lead to impressive gains in efficiency. Efforts to increase efficiency in water use could, however, have serious impacts on poor farmers, who may not be able to finance technological improvements. Hence, special assistance may be required to help poor farmers move up the technological ladder. Potentially greater saving can be achieved in delivering water, and the incentives for such improvements should be structured in such a way that the major beneficiaries (those who will avail of the "saved" water) contribute their share of the costs.

Groundwater irrigation presents a special case of too much of a good thing. Rapid expansion of groundwater irrigation during the last two decades, initiated using public funding but now largely driven by private investment, provided remarkable increases in yield, productivity, and area of irrigated crops in parts of rural Bangladesh, PRC, India, Indonesia, and Pakistan. However, unregulated extraction over vast areas has caused extensive and rapid lowering of the water table and, in coastal areas, contributed to saltwater intrusion. In other parts, overwatering (combined with inadequate drainage) is bringing the water table dangerously close to the ground surface, rendering the surface saline and unusable. The productivity of some areas is now so threatened that large investments will be needed to avert complete collapse of the resource base, as described in the box below.

Waterlogging and Salinity in Pakistan

Pakistan's Indus Basin irrigation system is the largest contiguous irrigation system in the world with three major dams, 19 barrages, and 43 interlinked canal systems. This vast system is served by an equally large drainage network commanding about 6 million hectares (ha). More than 400,000 tubewells (mostly privately owned) provide groundwater to supplement the surface canal supplies.

As a result of inequitable water application and inadequate drainage, 38 percent of the irrigated area is now waterlogged. In addition, irrigation adds more than 1.2 tons of salt per year to each ha. The salt is carried into the root zone where it reduces yields. The high rates of evaporation characteristic of the region's semiarid climate have rendered 14 percent of the surface too saline for use.

Recognizing the seriousness of the waterlogging and salinity problems, the Government began an extensive and costly reclamation program in 1959. Originally focused on providing surface and subsurface drainage, the program later included canal remodeling and selective lining to reduce aquifer recharge.

The Government's 1993 Drainage Sector Environmental Assessment recommended measures for overcoming the waterlogging and salinity problems:

  • precluding further developments that would mobilize salt from deep groundwater aquifers,
  • restricting irrigation to areas where existing drainage is adequate,
  • ceasing public investment for drainage where improvements could reasonably be carried out by the private sector,
  • restricting subsurface drainage interventions to areas affected by saline groundwater, and only where there is an environmentally acceptable means of eliminating drainage effluent,
  • concentrating surface drainage interventions to areas at risk of storm water damage, and
  • giving special attention to beneficiary participation in both structural and nonstructural interventions.

It is recognized that structural interventions to control waterlogging and salinity need to be complemented by agricultural strategies that promote the efficient use of water, beginning at the national level and continuing to the field level. Accordingly, in 1995 the Government adopted a long-term strategy for institutional reforms in the water sector. The role of the Government was redefined with the objective of phasing out subsidies for operation and maintenance of irrigation schemes within 10 years, and decentralizing management of irrigation and drainage services. Separate organizations will be established for operation and maintenance of each main canal system, and secondary irrigation and drainage systems will be transferred to farmer organizations. Implementation started in 1996 and is being supported by major international financiers, including ADB, World Bank, and Japan Bank for International Cooperation.

Despite such environmental problems, irrigated agriculture continues to support the country's economic development and provides livelihood for millions of families.

____________________
  1. A large part of these losses returns to rivers through the drainage network and as groundwater seepage and is, therefore, not lost from the river system, although the quality of return flows is often poor and limits their usefulness.


<<Back
From Development to Water Resource Management
Next>>
Future Water Resource Projects