Independent Evaluation

Home : Sectors and Themes : Independent Evaluation


OED Undertakes Independent Evaluation of ADB’s Safeguard Policies

The Operations Evaluation Department has completed its evaluation of ADB’s three safeguard policies [ PDF ]. This evaluation complemented ADB’s pending review of the safeguard policies, led by the Regional and Sustainable Development Department.

Objectives

The objectives of the evaluation were to

  • provide an independent assessment of ADB’s environmental and social safeguards with respect to results on the ground, particularly in terms of actual impacts of ADB-supported projects; and
  • identify key issues needed for the consideration of improvements to the safeguard policies, procedures, and their implementation.

The case study countries were India, the People’s Republic of China, the Philippines, and Viet Nam.

Methodologies

The main methodologies used include

  • desktop research and review of documents
  • consultations with stakeholders
  • project case studies in the four case study countries
  • questionnaire surveys for ADB’s operational staff and executing agencies of selected ongoing projects
  • interviews with selected directors of ADB’s sector divisions, safeguard specialists, and heads of project administrative units.

Contacts

Inquiries may be coursed through evaluation@adb.org.

Updates

DATE UPDATE
14 Jan 2008 Involuntary Resettlement Policy: Evaluation Case Studies
30 Mar 2007 Case Studies Covered by the three Safeguard Policies' Evaluations, and Field Visits Conducted [ PDF: 65kb | 2 pages ]
23 Mar 2007 Development Effectiveness Comittee response to the SES on Indigenous Peoples Safeguards [ PDF: 24kb | 3 pages ]
17 Mar 2007 Management Response to the Special Evaluation Study on Indigenous Peoples Safeguards [ PDF: 13kb | 3 pages ]
22 Feb 2007 Special Evaluation Study of ADB's Indigenous Peoples Safeguards: Final Report
22 Dec 2006 Development Effectiveness Comittee response to the SES on Environmental Safeguards and to the SES on Involuntary Resettlement Safeguards [ PDF: 23kb | 5 pages ]
21 Dec 2006 Status Update [ PDF: 18kb | 1 page ]
13 Oct 2006 Status Update [ PDF: 19kb | 1 page ]
6 Oct 2006 ADB Management's Response to: Special Evaluation Study on Involuntary Resettlement Safeguards: Final Report [ PDF: 15kb | 4 pages]
26 Sep 2006 Special Evaluation Study on Involuntary Resettlement Safeguards: Final Report
22 Sep 2006 ADB Management's Response to Special Evaluation Study of Environmental Safeguards: Final Report [ PDF: 21kb | 5 pages ]
12 Sep 2006 Special Evaluation Study of Environmental Safeguards: Final Report
4 May 2006 Powerpoint presentation [ PDF: 165kb | 34 pages ] presented for the ADB Annual Meeting in Hyderabad, India

Stakeholder Feedback

DATE FEEDBACK
4 July 2007 Feedback [ PDF: 280kb | 21 pages ] from Forest Peoples Programme on SES on Indigenous Peoples Policy
27 Jan 2007 Feedback [ PDF: 208kb | 24 pages ] on SES on Involuntary Resettlement Safeguards from Joanna Levitt, Director of Programs, International Accountability Project, Berkeley, California
27 Nov 2006 Feedback [ PDF: 43kb | 10 pages ] on SES on Involuntary Resettlement Policy from Susanna Price, Former Senior Social Development Specialist, ADB; Presently Visiting Fellow in the Department of Anthropology, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies at the Australian National University, Canberra
2 Nov 2006 Feedback [ PDF: 88kb | 9 pages ] from NGO Forum on ADB: SES on Environmental Safeguards Policy
2 Nov 2006 Feedback [ PDF: 68kb | 7 pages ] from NGO Forum on ADB: SES on Involuntary Resettlement Policy