Evaluation Resources

Validates the completion report’s assessment of the project, which aimed at enhanced access to land, water, markets, services, agricultural inputs, technologies, and jobs for people living in barani or rural areas outside Pakistan's extensive irrigation system. IED overall assessment: Successful

Validates the completion report’s assessment of the project, which aimed to sustain and improve agricultural practices through better natural resources management, enhance community infrastructure, and improve rural livelihood opportunities and alternatives. IED overall assessment: Successful

Validates the completion report’s assessment of the project, whose outcomes were to increase agriculture production, job opportunities, and farm income in the project area by extending the main canal and irrigation system, and providing facilities for surface drainage and on-farm water management. IED overall assessment: Less than successful.

Validates the PCR's assessment of the project which aims to assist the government of Pakistan to define, plan, prepare, and implement an environment for infrastructure development consistent with the country's medium-term development framework.

Validates the completion report’s assessment of the project aimed to raise the per capita income of the project area beneficiaries to attain or exceed the poverty line, and improve the human resource and income-generating potential of women in the project area.

Validates the completion report's assessment of the Project which aims to protect and improve the hilly and mountainous environment of the North-West Frontier Province in Pakistan, thereby increasing the productivity of private, community, and government lands suitable for trees, fodder, and other crops. IED overall assessment: Partly Successful.

Validates the completion report's assessment of the Project aimed at reducing poverty in four districts in southern Sindh by boosting empowerment and improving governance, widening access of the rural poor to public services, transferring technology to improve livelihoods, and providing essential infrastructure. IED overall assessment: Unsuccessful.

On 21 September 2009, the Director General of the Independent Evaluation Department of the Asian Development Bank received this response from the Managing Director General on behalf of Management on the Impact Evaluation Study of Rural Water Supply and Sanitation in Punjab, Pakistan.

Validates the completion report's assessment of the project designed to improve drainage system, drainage operations and maintenance, and agricultural production in Pakistan. The project also embarked on improving capability of the public sector to plan and implement water sector projects. IED overall assessment: Unsuccessful.

Validates the completion report's assessment of the project aimed to increase rural incomes, employment, and quality of life through improvements in irrigation and road infrastructure, community development, provision of financial services, and institutional support through organizational and skills training for beneficiaries in village communities of Pakistan. IED overall assessment: Successful.